G Wiv - Thanks for mentioning The Spice House. They have a new location in Geneva and I went there.
I also went to Caputos. They did not have the old product I once bought there that wasn't really Mexican oregano. I guess they realized their error and dumped that product.
Caputos did have these two products:
San Miguel Oregano
Mi Costenita Oregano
At The Spice House I bought:
Closeup of the label:
Both the San Miguel and the Mi Costenita were whole (Entero) - they seem like highly comparable products. Both seemed very nice.
The Spice House product is more crushed. It's a darker green color, I don't know why.
Comparing the aromas - I think ALL THREE of these products were the same.
For the record, I bought some greek oregano at the spice house as well - that's 100% different.
So good news, I made too big a deal out of it, Mexican Oregano is easy to find.