Quote:
On an even stranger note, many elderly Swedes consider
Gyromitra esculenta a delicacy after parboiling them repeatedly to remove the toxins. Recent research has shown, however, that variations in the mushrooms and/or the parboiling and/or an accumulation of toxins in frequent eaters may lead to poisoning despite decades of symptom-free consumption. These days, the mushroom is labelled as poisonous in all mushrooms books (Wikipedia has puzzlingly labeled them as both "choice" and "deadly"!) but
can still be served in restaurants where it is assumed that professional chefs can properly handle them. So, keeping up with research also has a factor in mushroom identification...
(Finding Gyromitra esculenta) These are not an issue in the Chicago area. While the Gyromitra esculenta looks like a brain on a stem, it is hefty and when cut in half is a solid mass. Whereas a morel cut in half is light weight and hollow inside. Those who mistakenly ID a Gyromatra esculenta often believe they won the morel sweepstakes because they are so generously sized.
...
In Missouri, Gyromitra esculenta's are nicknamed 'Big Red' with some people actively seeking them out. There were some rumors people in Michigan were also eating them. A friend went to a diner to check this by making casual conversation. One waitress advised, "I personally will not eat them, though I do prepare them for my husband." Her recitation of this anecdote was snort coffee through your nose moment for my mushroom friends. I'm sure there are Illinois residents who hunt them, I just don't have a related anecdote for them!
The False Morel
Gyromitra esculenta , which pops up during morel season in various regions, is consider poisonous due to hydrazine. Just as often as false morels mentioned, the usual caution is stated, "False morels have hydrazine, which is a component in jet fuel. Do not eat it." Accordind to Tom Volk, "The active ingredient is called gyromitrin (N-methyl-N-formylhydrazine), which is metabolized to monomethylhydrazine (rocket fuel!) in the body." Despite the warnings, there are people who eat it anyway. The hydrazine has an accumulative effect, a gathering storm mind you, because it never leaves your system. You can eat them over some years with no ill effect, then once you have passed a certain threshold you have liver failure and chronic health problems. However depending on your body chemistry and general health, the consumption of the false morel can affect you quicker. There is research to suggest hydrazine can trigger tumors, which really isn't a swell residual affect from dining.
If you want to learn the straight story on the false morel, then please read
Tom Volk's Fungus of the Month: Gyromitra esculenta, one of the false morels for complete information.
There is no way a professional chef can prepare a Gyromitra esculenta and render it safe.
Bridgestone wrote:
This leads me to believe that there is a decent amount of culture and tradition involved in choosing non-poisonous mushrooms for the kitchen. What is "tasty" in Russia may well not be "tasty" in Vienna.
Long ago I was at a weekend cottage in Croatia, the owners had just returned from the woods with a quantity of mushrooms. When they learned I was an American, they lectured me quite angrily, "There would be more known edible mushrooms in America if you Americans had treated the Indians better." In North America, the English culture with their adversion of mushrooms has a lot to do with our culture's fear of wild mushrooms.
While there is certainly a mushroom affinitity very strongly in Eastern Europe and Russia, this was largely influenced by the Orthodox church. They had many extended periods of fasting where one abstained from meat, mushrooms with their meaty textures and flavor became a meat substitute. People in those countries learn their mushrooming anecdotally from one person to another with only the good (edible) collected and everything else is declared bad. Years ago, I had a Russian emigree who worked for us in Chicago. She told me she knew everything about mushrooms. I went a on a brief vacation to Wisconsin, I collected one mushroom of everything I saw. I laid everything neatly on a newspaper for her inspection. I already had in my mind a Royal Russian Feast dancing through my mind of preparing all these mushrooms in a sour cream sauce for lunch. Of the 40 different mushrooms on the table, she picked exactly two as edible. I quickly surmised her knowledge was limited and joined a mushroom club.
What one rarely sees in these mushroom collecting cultures are people who study the mushrooms beyond their favorite locally-prized edibles. I will surmise it is this reason why they have a limited edible vocabulary with the Austrians and Russians favoring and discounting each others finds.
The 'Death Angel' is from the Amanita family, which does have some known edibles. One friend's very first wild mushroom eating experience came from carefully identifying an edible in the Amanita family. Later when the full impact of what a mistake might have cost her, she never again even tempted to eat to anything from the Amanita family.
MHays wrote:
I will never forget my brief discussion with the mycologist at the Field Museum, who is very excited about edible mushrooms and eager to share his knowledge. He told a story about a couple from France foraging here, insisting that they knew what they were doing - but they didn't know that locally,
Chanterelles have a poisonous look-alike, the
Jack-O-Lantern, which apparently doesn't grow in Europe - they became quite ill. Though I'd agree about culture, it's also possible that you have a lookalike or poisonous variety there.
I will guess you were talking to Greg Mueller.
Chanterelles rarely grow in clusters nor are they in the midwest very sizeable compared to the Jack O Lantern. When people encounter the Jack O-Lantern, they believe they hit the jackpot because of the size and quantity. They very much want it to be a chanterelle and will ignore their guidebooks. You won't die, but you will be so sick you will wish you were dead. Personally, I have come to the conclusion when people ignore the available information because of their hopefullness, then perhaps it is a bit of greed peaking in.
Regards,
_________________
Cathy2
"You'll be remembered long after you're dead if you make good gravy, mashed potatoes and biscuits." -- Nathalie Dupree
Facebook,
Twitter,
Greater Midwest Foodways,
Road Food 2012: Podcast