Lunch today at PGC was a very nice experience thanks largely to the terrific company, but I have to say I'm less enthusiastic about the restaurant. Everything I tasted was good, but nothing really stood out to me as making PGC a special place to dine. I thought the best item was the warm Bennison's bakery baguette.
The table ordered appetizers to share, and my generous companions who ordered additional starters let me taste theirs. "Spicy Chicken Wings" were hot and juicy, but too mild for the moniker. I'd put them solidly in the top third of mild wings served at pubs in CollegeTown, USA. "Greek fries" had tasty toppings, but the potatoes themselves were too limp. (Full disclosure: I am at odds with the British practice of putting malt vinegar on fries, as it invariably makes them soggy; so it's not surprising that these vinegar-topped fries were not to my taste.) "Tortilla soup" was tasty, but would have been better named "Tomato soup," as I found the flavor one-dimensional tomatoey, with plenty of what I assume was cream for richness. A good, seasonal soup, but I guess the expectation had been set in my mind for something a little more exciting. Dialing back of flavor was a fairly consistent theme to me, as the chicken caesar salad - while also fine - had just a bare whif of anchovy (the chicken in the salad, otoh, was a very tasty grilled breast - cooked about as well as I could imagine this cut being prepared). Guacamole was perhaps the most flavorful of the starters, but the chips were too thin and - to be honest - not all that fresh, in my opinion.
I'll spare you the detailed descriptions of the lamb sausage, tuna melt, pasta, and other entrees. I thought they were all good, but wouldn't describe any of them with much more ebullient adjectives than that.
There was one outstanding dessert: a huge, gooey, hot chocolate chip cookie topped with vanilla ice cream. The rest were also good, but I have to say - for a place I thought had a focus on seasonality, it was surprising to see such ubiquitous and heavy-handed use of supermarket-quality, white-in-the-center, made-for-shipping-not-eating, strawberries. Where were the season's peaches, pears, apples, plums, etc.?
I have no strong opposition to this nomination if it resonates with others in our community - just thought I'd share that there's at least one LTHer who isn't all that enthused about PGC.
_________________
...defended from strong temptations to social ambition by a still stronger taste for tripe and onions." Screwtape in
The Screwtape Letters by CS Lewis
Fuckerberg on Food