We stopped into Three Brothers for some Serbian food over the weekend. They were written up in the
NY Times a while ago, and it sounded pretty good. It's located on a residential street and the parking is all street parking in front of houses so it has the feel of visiting a friend's house for a dinner party. The space has a very charming old-school tavern feel and formica tables. (Reservations are highly recommended)
The menu promotes the burek that takes 45 minutes to cook. So of course we ordered two. We started with a couple orders of chicken dumpling soup. The entire meal had a very home-cooked quality to it, especially the soup. The broth had a bold, hearty chicken flavor and the dumplings were soft and crumbly.

They also brought a simple salad of fresh lettuce and tomatoes topped with a vinaigrette. The two courses held us over while we waited for the bureks to cook. And they were definitely worth the wait. We ordered both the spinach and cheese and the beef and both were excellent. The top of the burek was well browned and the inside very gooey and rich.

We also ordered the roasted free range goose and the stuffed grape leaves. They warned us when we ordered the goose that they could not get the skin crispy without drying out the meat. The meat was very full-flavored and moist so we didn't mind at all. It was served with a big spoonful of stuffing. The goose was the only entree that didn't remind me of the home-cooked Turkish food I grew up on.

The grape leaves were stuffed with ground beef and served with a side of spongy dumplings and gravy made from what I assume is the cooking water. The stuffed grape leaves were nice and sour and not overcooked at all which can be a problem with dolmas.

This was an excellent meal top to bottom. It's a pretty unique setting with a laid-back atmosphere and huge servings of Eastern European comfort food. I'd never had Serbian food before, but the dishes were similar enough to Turkish food that I felt like I was visiting a relative.
Three Brothers Bar & Restaurant
2414 S Saint Clair St
Milwaukee, WI 53207
(414) 481-7530