In general, I have to say that my 2004 adventures included a lot of disappointments - and some really bad meals.
Well, here we go.
Ten great experiences in no particular order:
1) Big E's Soul Food in Minneapolis - often touted and worth the time it took to find. Some great food.
2) Sponge Candy - IGA in Eganville, ON - I am walking toward the check out and I see sponges for C$1. I look at them and they are NOT sponges but sponge candy. No company name or ingredients. In cellophane with a 1"x1" paper saying "sponge candy." Bought a couple and they were great.
3) Erich Schat's Bakery in Bishop, CA - A chance encounter in 1992 on a long road trip prompted me to head to Bishop rather than taking the long route between Reno and Las Vegas.
4) The China Date Ranch, Tecopa Springs, CA - I thought I did not like dates ... just never had any good ones. A great drive in a hidden canyon, 100 miles out of Las Vegas.
5) The Boudin Tour in SW Louisiana - Decided to try boudin at the Boudin King in Opelousas, LA and ended up trying it at six other stands. His was the best. Do not do a u-turn on a busy highway. The locals don't like it.
6) McIlhenney's Plantation on Avery Island, LA - trying 15 different sauces and finishing with pepper sauce ice cream was a great treat. Then a co-worker ordered a monster basket sent to me as a gift.
7) Almond's Restaurant in Clayton, MO - After years of trips to St. Louis going to the old favorites, I asked a coworker to book me a reservation at his favorite STL restaurant. Great Cajun inspired service and an owner who provided phenomenal service.

Maggione's - Woodfield - My boss sent me there to check out their catering option and they put out quite a spread - a lot better than some that I have seen. And the food was surprisingly good. You could do a whole lot worse.
9) Chuck's Southern Cooking - another well-hyped place that lives up to the hype. Had four completely incompatable dishes by my own choice and all were excellent.
10) Biltoki - Elko, NV - what a spread. Put out enough food for the two of us to feed ten and most of it is pretty good.
Other places worth a mention: Makino Sushi and Seafood Buffet in Las Vegas, Round the Clock in Crystal Lake, Big Mama's in Las Vegas.
The Disappointments:
1) Texan BBQ, Algonquin - FIRST meal of the year. Dried out tasteless brisket - and my wife wanted to go to Famous Dave's that evening.
2) Soochow, Reno, NV - The problem with relying on Chowhound recommendations is that the food on the normal menu does not match what is offered on special menus.
3) Lotus of Siam, Las Vegas - two meals - Let me guess - "the owner was in Thailand, I did not give the secret CH handshake." Not bad food, just not any better than average,
4) Gerlach (NV) Country Club - touted as the best restaurant around - well, the ONLY restaurant around. I did not know that you could serve ravioli swimming in that much grease.
5) Swiss Chalet, Ottawa, ON - I give all chains a fair shot. This place used to be good. It is really bad, really bad.
6) Red Dragon, Columbus, OH - avoid any restaurant in an old Red Robin location.