That’s a little shocking to me. We routinely get Piece because it’s down the street from us, and our standard order of one large pepperoni and one large sausage comes in under $60, if memory serves. What’s sort of annoying is that they charge full freight for a topping whether you get it on the whole pie, or half of the pie, which seems wrong to me but tolerable given the product.
My main bitch about Piece is not the prices but the crabby staff. JFC they are angry to see you and serve you. The bouncers act like it’s a crime to have kids there after 6, and the servers like you have a social disease if you ask a question. I’ve pretty much stopped going there because of it, but do the take-out still because I don’t feel like John’s on Western all the time.
Bucktown could use another solid option.