Just a reminder note that some of the restaurants mentioned on this thread may have gone out of business so if you are traveling to Door County, check to see before you go. You can easily do this by checking the Destination Door County website or google the restaurant.
Some of our favorites are Chop, Lure, Alexanders, Barringers, Chives, and Harbor Fish Market and Grill. Chop and Lure have a great early bird special. They all take reservations which you almost have to have, especially in high season. Wickman House too, but you have to make reservations well in advance on Tock. For pub grub, burgers, and rubens and the like, we like Mink River Basin, Husby's Northern Grill, Coyote Road House and Cornerstone Pub.
Not recommended are English Inn, and Sister Bay bowl. We don't think the food is good or up to the hype. Al Johnson's is difficult to ignore. Its a sentimental favorite for me as my parents brought me as a young girl. Love the ambience and Swedish pancakes (mostly in off season when it not as crowded) but can't find much else to love on the menu. Have not gone to the beer garden but its popular. Love browsing the butiks. La Cocina delivers pizza to northern door county so check it out if you are renting an air bnb or cottage. Also Piggly wiggly has good broasted chicken for take out to pair with potato salad. Ice Cream Factory has good sandwiches and pannini, you can eat in or takeout. There is a growing food truck scene, with Wally's Weenie Wagon, and Savor BBQ and others, both are pretty good. Hugel Haus for German food is worth a mention with their true Wisconsin atmosphere
(and stuffed bear).
Don't miss Charlie's Smokehouse for smoked fish and Seaquist Farm market for cherry pie and a bunch of other stuff. This is a quick update, there are many more that could be mentioned. P.S. Don't expect Chicago style standards when it comes to food but there are still some good eats.
Toria
"I like this place and willingly could waste my time in it" - As You Like It,
W. Shakespeare