Glutton for punishment that I (occasionally) am, and it being a beautiful sunny day in the low 80'sF, I decided to fire up the woodburning offset today and smoke some spare ribs. I'd done several low & slow cooks in a row on my newish pellet grill and I thought it would be useful to stay in practice on the big rig. That very well may have been the case but I ain't gonna lie. It's a ton more work for an outcome that is only marginally better (Is it even better? More on that below). These were labeled as St. Louis but when you buy at Costco, you never really know how they'll be butchered, and in this case, they definitely still had some tips attached, which was fine . . .
Spare Rib Mise En Place & Kanehide Bessaku Semi Stainless Honesuki, 150mm/lefty Spare ribs, 16-mesh black pepper, Morton Kosher salt, my SPG rub, Plochman's yellow mustard and my BBQ rub. Racks trimmed and membranes removed, I undercoated these with a bit of the yellow mustard, then hit each of them with a different combination of the seasonings and rubs. I wouldn't call this a scientific comparison but I figured I'd try 3 different combos. So, just s& p on one, BBQ rub on another and the SPG on the third one.
Wood Pile & Hults Bruk 20" Aneby Hunting AxeMy wood pile is a combination of apple, oak and hickory. In order to keep my fire burning within the desired range (and not add any discernible creosote notes), I figured this was roughly the size of split I needed to add to it every ~15-20 minutes. Compact for quick combustion, large enough to maintain temperature and yet, not so small that I had to add wood any more frequently.
FireboxThis was my initial fire, started with four quarter logs, burned way down. A few minutes later, it was time to put the rubbed rib racks in the cooker . . .
Starting The RibsAt this point, the cooking chamber was fluctuating nicely between 275-300F. About every 15-20 minutes after this, I dropped what I was doing, went out to the cooker, added another of those splits of wood to the fire and spritzed the ribs with a mix of apple juice and apple cider vinegar. Adding the splits in this manner did help keep the temperature at right around the same level for a couple of hours, and their size definitely mitigated any off notes. Spritzing helped keep the ribs from drying out.
With the ribs on their way, it was time for some side-dishery . . .
Bean Mise & Place & Takeda Stainless Clad Sasanoha, 190mmSalt, garlic, Rancho Gordo Buckeye Beans, evoo, black pepper, slitted jalapenos and buena mulatas, yellow onion and bay leaves. Decided to do these on a whim, so a rare, no-soak cook. As fresh as they were, they took quite a bit longer than soaked beans usually take (~5 hours over the usual 2-3). That was okay, though. I had plenty of time.
Meanwhile . . .
Horizon Offset CookerAfter about 2.5 hours the ribs had reached ~150F internal, and I decided it was time to wrap them in butcher paper for the duration of the cook. Before that, I opened the cooker up and grabbed a shot.
Pre-wrapped Ribs~2.5 hours into the cook. Looking pretty good, with nice color and bark. Time to wrap. That's my spritz bottle sneaking into the shot on the left!
Once the ribs reached ~200F internal, took them off the cooker, let them rest a bit, unwrapped them and threw them back on the cooker for a few minutes to tack them up. After that, time to eat . . .
Plated UpWith some of the season's final corn from 3SG and a blob of the weekly slaw. It ended up being a bit ambitious to think I could eat two of each of the three kinds of ribs. I did manage to snarf down 4/6, though.
Now, were these really better than ribs I cooked a few weeks ago on my pellet grill? In my mind, they were not. The two cooks were on par with each other but for me there was no discernible qualitative difference between the ribs via these two cooking methods. Could that come down to factors beyond the rig? Absolutely. While I've cooked ribs dozens of times over the past three decades, that still pretty much makes me a n00b. In more skilled/experienced hands, would there have been a more profound difference between the two cooking methods? Perhaps but the more I cook on my pellet grill and the more I read and learn about others' experiences with these cookers, I'm beginning to believe that the gap -- if there is one -- is pretty small. Meanwhile, I can't say that spending the bulk of my day tending to a fire was the best use of my time.
=R=
Same planet, different world